Best Rated Gay First Time Sex Stories - Page 7

First Time Frat Brother Story

I had allegedly gotten a single to take conquered babes to after parties...though Mike was a babe definitely worth conquering :-) There were a few occaisions that he and I basically got caught with our pants down! There would be an unplanned knock on the door, and we would either have to pretend there was nobody in the room (a difficult task, given that there was moaning coming out of the room just seconds earlier), or hope that we could get our pants on fast enough to make things seem kosher. .... Despite a lot of great firsts, after Mike and I broke up it took me over 2 years for me to accept the fact that I was gay. I know where he is now though...he's a great friend, and I'll never forget him and my first time.
3.6 775 words 3 mins fraternity

Short Story About First Time Camping

It was late and we just finished putting the tent up. We were getting ready to go to sleep when my friend went to close the tent windows and he was wearing nothing and he was very hard. I was in my sleeping bag and just seeing him got me very hard. He was just walking around the tent not saying to much.
2.9 234 words 1 mins twink  teen

Gay First Time with Girlfriend's Older Brother

I was 19 then, and I'm 6'1" tall, weigh 175, have brownish-blond hair and green eyes. I've got a muscular build, and I'm smooth, so I suppose I have what's called a "swimmer's build. Sherry doesn't really fit into the story, as you'll see, but her brother does, so let me describe him to you. His name was Gary and he was a couple of years older than me - I think he was 23.
3.6 1548 words 7 mins friendship

Short Story About Catching Macho Brother Sucking Cock and First Time Getting Sucked

i was sitting in the kitchen when i heard noises comming from my older brothers room. i went down the hall and listened at the door, sure enough he was banging something, sounded like squeaks and bangs. Thought he was fucking some girl, but boy was I mistaken!
3.5 461 words 2 mins anal sex fucking

First Time Calling Up an Classified Ad in The Paper

Slowly at first then with more eagerness I took his manhood in my mouth and licked and sucked. I tried to take it all but I kept gaging. We moved into a sixty nine position and I lost all track of time. I lay on my back with M.'s dick slowly sliding in and out of my mouth, his balls would come to a rest on my nose before his dick would begin sliding back out. All the while he sucked my hard cock.
3.5 522 words 2 mins anal sex fucking

Short Story About First Time For College Student

"Look at my pants." I looked; I didn't see anything. He continued, "I've had a fantasy for a long time about making it with you or Mike. I want you to prove to me you're really gay. I want you to do to me whatever gay guys do to each other." I looked at his pants again. Now I saw it. A big, hard cock, just poking its head through the leg. I couldn't believe it. Bill. Mr. Macho had a fantasy for me. But I knew it was impossible; I wasn't going to fall for the oldest line in the book about "proving it." But I did.
3.2 362 words 2 mins hunk muscular  big cock

Two 18 Year Olds Kiss And Cum Together

I have a lot of fantasies about having sex with other guys, and last night I finally did it. Here's how it was. My friend Alan came over and we got talking about how horny we are. Alan is 18 like me and we met when we were at school. He's about 5'10" and he has blond hair and blue eyes. I'm taller than him and I have dark hair.
3.4 511 words 2 mins friendship shower

First Time Short Story

Touching him in so intimate a way snapped something inside me, and, giving in to my newly-awakening sexual appetite, I slowly lowered myself to my knees in front of Mark. I could see his whole body now, and I thought briefly of allowing him to wake up to my caresses. But I realized that, good Catholic boy that he was, Mark would flip out and our friendship might never be the same. I couldn't risk it. Still, this might be the only time I would ever get this opportunity.....
3.1 636 words 3 mins

Short Story About First Time Sex with Two Latin Studs

The moment arrived when he started stroking his thick and long cock through his trousers. I placed my hand on it and he pushed it away. "I no like that," he said with his broken English. I withdrew my hand for a few minutes and tried again. This time he didn't reject my hand and when Lico saw this he put his arm around Manuel.
3.8 492 words 2 mins latino  big cock  blowjob

Short Story about First Time in a Park

I just the spent the weekend at my aunts house and was heading home. Well I was walking down this rather busy street and this guy comes into view. He asks if I want to have my cock sucked.
3.7 275 words 1 mins

Become a Patreon to help us grow the site

Post Your Stories on Taletopia