Best Rated Gay Sex Stories - Page 2

Barber Of Beaverton

I couldn't believe it. I'd just left the house of a straight guy I'd managed to seduce on the train. He was close enough to my type, and was a bottom to boot. Who knew? As I left his place, my mind turned to more practical matters. My hair hadn't been cut in weeks, and was starting to look pretty ridiculous.
4.6 friendship straight men

My Worst Cockfight Defeat

We met at a friends apartment, put down a plastic tarp and went over the rules. It would be an erotic oil first-to-cum-loses wrestling match, we would use any means to force the other man to shoot first. I chose a white thong to wear which barely contained my swelling 8" cut cock.
4.5 athletic big cock  bubble butt  shaving

Adventurous Shopping Trip

He was working in one of the clothes stores I went into. A place I usually went to to buy my designer lables. I hadn't seen him there before, but I took a good long look at him. He was about my height, 6', maybe a little taller, with short black hair, and the deepest green eyes I had ever seen. He was thin, but not too thin, just right.
4.5 beginnings balls sucking

Tennis Tops and Bottoms

Jimmy meets the son of his land lady and they end up going to a sports complex near by. There I meet plenty of people interested in what I have to offer.
4.5 athletic hairy  hunk muscular  balls sucking  big cock  blowjob  deepthroat  massage  rimming  locker room  pool  shower

Sucking and getting fucked in the Morning

Tom and Gary are room mates and lovers. Tom was tall and blond, while Gary on the other hand was short and dark. Tom looks at his boyfriend naked form and his huge penis with excited lust!
4.5 relationship anal sex fucking  big cock  shower

Gaysex with the UPS delivery man

His Mediterranean good looks seemed enhanced by the standard brown uniform all UPS drivers wore. We become befriended and he pops round my place to hang out and smoke. I prep the place with porn, hoping for the best...
4.5 encounters blowjob

Skinny dipping with Carl

Carl gets better after my tutoring and to reward ourselves we go skinny dipping together. Sparks start flying...
4.5 anal sex fucking  hunk muscular  balls sucking  big cock

Cruising the Net for a Fuck

Sick of only having been with men who wanted to blow me, I finally find an online date who is into some anal action, but he wants to fuck me and I was never a bottom... before...
4.5 first time hairy  rimming

Shaving Together as Couples Do

With his pale skin and black kinky hair he told me he shaved almost every afternoon or whenever he was going to see me. His satiny skin and scrawny body made him my favorite physical type. When I saw him last week I'd told him that he wasn't to shave anything except his face until he next saw me. Normally very submissive he objected saying the regrowing hair would itch and drive him mad.
4.5 relationship shaving

The Gardener Gets Fucked

He was hired back in January, and he caught my eye, bundled up in a varsity letter jacket, shoveling snow from the walkways. When spring came, his attire changed to a orange v-neck baseball shirt and a red baseball cap, jeans and light brown Timberlands. Bryan was short, rather short, just 5'5", and that sizzled my desires. I'm a tall guy, 6'4", and I really dig short guys.
4.5 beginnings anal sex fucking  deepthroat  pool